I first noticed a hint of this when he was asked to stand and speak at an Australian Sailing Awards the previous year about the Mexico Olympics, where he began and then stopped, then started and stopped again, his account a Swiss cheese of accurate facts and silent holes.
Carl had recently visited his doctor and, driving one of his beloved Italian sports cars, had gone in to take some tests then had his car keys quietly taken from him.
Quite quickly, things began to happen. With his children close by, Carl moved into full-time medical care and, over the past two years, I would book a Zoom meeting through the staff and continue to chat with Carl.
I think he recognised me a couple of times, but I could see from his eyes he wasn’t sure who I was. His son, perhaps? No. And was Blue a person, a concept, or simply just a colour?
And so, after ten remarkable years of Carl telling me about his life, I started to tell him about his life.
The staff encouraged this, to try to help with his memory, and so with nurses sitting either side of him, over the months I spoke of Benny and the timber Finn.
I spoke of Carl winning Australian Championships with his mates, about the replica of Benny’s 1961 World Championship-winning 18-foot skiff Venom, which Carl had painstakingly built and stored in his garage to keep the memory alive as the original rotted away near oyster beds in Queensland.
Of how Benny’s Taipan and Venom designs revolutionised the 18-foot skiff class, both blisteringly fast and controversial in equal measure, not for the last time in Lexcen’s career.
Of Carl travelling to the United States in 2006 to present the America’s Cup Hall of Fame with a replica of the rudder from the Taipan, complete with winglets that Benny was working on 24 years before Australia II.
I also spoke to Carl about him travelling to Denmark to stay with his close friend Paul Elvstrom at his home, which was stunning news to the Danish locals who regarded Paul as a bit of a hermit.
It was easy to see how Carl’s warmth and easy charm forged deep friendships all over the world.
I then spoke about how Alan Bond and Warren Jones had invited him over to Perth in 1986 to bolster their Cup defence, as part of the afterguard on Australia lll, helping its victory in the 12-Metre World Championships.
Of back as a teenager on the weekends, heading off to regattas, where they would strap their Flying Dutchman to the roof of the family’s Holden, driving up to Lake Macquarie where they often sailed all night when the breeze held in, just for the love of sailing.
All of these anecdotes over many calls were met by a slight frown from Carl, a shake of the head and a quiet, “No. Sorry. I don’t know about any of that.”